Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

my 2 cents: A few days of outrage will do absolutely nothing to stop or change the law. AFAICT, many the EU bureaucrats and politicians fervently believe that they are doing the right thing here, even if it's clearly bonkers.

It's like Brexit that way.

Also: as said elsewhere, article 13 is probably all good news for YouTube, so I doubt that they do anything deeply confrontational. Plus, even if they did, they would just be portrayed as evil lobbying/scheming bastards arm twisting the EU into giving them what they want.



> as said elsewhere, article 13 is probably all good news for YouTube

This part is not clear to me. On one hand they are big enough to prevent copyrighted material being published. They could also offer filtering services to smaller parties.

But on the other hand, YouTube is still full of copyrighted material. You can find basically any videoclip, cd-rip, or anything else on there. There are even entire movie rips on there, that regularly get deleted. Do they currently pay some big license owner a fee for this? I don't think so (but I'm not sure).

So if this article 13 passes, YouTube will have to remove all of this material. Not only that, but they have to prevent such material being published in the first place. Or somehow make sure that a certain videoclip/cd-rip is payed off to the proper license owner.

I'm not sure if it's even possible for YouTube to make such a filter, without having either a lot of false negatives or positives.


> my 2 cents: A few days of outrage will do absolutely nothing to stop or change the law.

Yep, it's going to be just another "oh lol there's a protest" and a week later nobody remembers it.

I'd be happy if wikimedia just completely blocked all of Europe for a 2-3 weeks.


Well, there's an EU election soon, blocking for a couple of weeks before that would probably suffice to change a few minds.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: