Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

"Google knows better than you" gives way too much credit IMHO. Google Search is nearly useless for my most searched topics today, and even dangerous in that it gives you a very wrong perception of what is out there.



Any examples? I find it hard to believe it is "nearly useless for most searched topics". It is easy to check, go to your search history and look at your last 10-20 queries and count how many them useless.


Today I searched for TPUG, which is the Toronto PET Users Group.

Google returned exactly ZERO results about TPUG. All of the results were about dogs.


I just searched for TPUG on Google in both my logged in profile, as well as an incognito window. Both searches returned primarily results about the Toronto PET Users Group, including a knowledge panel specifically about the Toronto PET Users Group (founded in 1978 by Lyman Duggan).

That's either very quick turnaround to fix, or a deeper mystery!


No mystery at all. Google tailors the results to what it thinks you want, rather than what you asked for.

Two people sitting at machines next to each other can perform the same search and get different results. It's what Google's spent billions of dollars on.


I expect it to change results, it would be a terrible experience if it did not


The very first answer is Toronto Pet users for me, even with special box and the works.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: