Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

swaggyBoatswain's comment is responding to csytan's comment, not your post.



Ah...sorry lads! couldn't tell on mobile :-)


> sorry lads

Come on, we can do better than that. This isn't an ol' boys club.


In Ireland "lads" is (weirdly to British people) gender neutral and is used by men and women to refer to mixed groups of people.

I don't know if itsbenlee is Irish or in Ireland.


"Lads" is an appropriate, albeit very british, way of addressing men, which the poster above was doing. Why the noise?


Little disappointed to be so downvoted for calling this out; I don't really do it very often. Also a brit, but I didn't know that the others in the conversation were men. It's pretty easy to use `guys` instead.


I didn't downvote you.

But it was a short comment intended to convey "Oops! Sorry. My bad." So you basically replied to an apology with a suggestion that the apology had committed some greater sin.

My feeling is that probably falls under the heading "Throwing the baby out with the bathwater." I don't think it qualifies as a Best Practice for improving the social climate on some metric or other.

That's not intended to lecture you. I'm just trying to make conversation on a topic I find interesting. Given the nature of the beast, I'm having very mixed feelings about commenting at all.


"Guys" is just as gender-specific as "lads".


The defence was it was a Britishism, where guys is gender neutral.


I don't understand your post/replies. Do you have a problem with people using britishisms? The "defence" spelling is also a britishism, so I'm not sure where you're going with all that.

"Guys" is not any more gender neutral than "Lads" (they both are often used in a gender-neutral way, but they're etymologically male). "Folks" is what I personally use if I specifically want something gender-neutral, but "lads" is definitely appropriate if the author is speaking to men.

Which brings me back to "this is a lot of noise for nothing".


Literally the first definition of "guy" is "a man". "Guy" is only gender neutral when you're referring to a group of people.


Why not address all readers, instead of only men?


The poster above was not addressing readers, but rather three specific people.


Apparently you can use 'guys' now instead




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: