Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Yes! I am OK with only humans having a right to free speech.



Humans express their right to free speech through bots. It's no different from expressing your right to free speech through paid advertisements.


I think I am okay with contents from bots if they are marked like advertisements ("sponsored contents", etc.). For example, "post from ABC" could instead say "post from ABC, a bot account of XYZ".


Are you OK with dishonest speech?

If so, then not marking bot speech as such is mere dishonesty.

Not to mention that, in the general case of speech, I do not have to disclose if I am being paid to express my viewpoint.


I am okay with dishonest speech (or paid speech, for that matter), because it affects your reputation. Sockpuppets and bots harm reputation tracking.


Nobody in the real world - outside the ivory tower - actually cares about tracking the reputation of a PAC that was spun up for an election in order to run political ads, and will disappear in two months.

What makes a bot any different?


Not really. There are disclosure rules for paid advertisements. People can express whatever they want through a bot, as long as they also make it clear that this expression is being delivered by a bot.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: