Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The divided mind / healing back pain - Books by John E. Sarno.

To give you a background I have struggled with back pain all my life. After dozens of MRIs, X rays, physiotherapy, ayurveda, yoga, posture exercises, and spending almost 100,000 in the last 15 years on this, a simple book saved me.

The effect was so powerful that I could feel the symptoms fading while I was reading it. It gave me my life back. A few weeks ago I finally had the courage to teach my little one to walk without worrying about bending my back.

Now I feel that more people suffering from back pain, chronic fatigue, etc should be made aware of it. Here is a intro video about it [1]

P.S. I credit hacker news for the source.

[1] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vsR4wydiIBI



Also, for anyone interested, there is a brilliant 2016 documentary film 'All the Rage, Saved by Sarno'

Here's Dr.Sarno's words at the end of movie trailer: 'All this because of one simple idea — that the mind and the body intimately connected'


I couldn't find a place to buy it online. Do yoh have a link? Thanks


Sure, I found one here on Vimeo. https://vimeo.com/ondemand/alltherage

also, the official website http://alltheragedoc.com/


Thank you for this. I needed this


Just as a follow up, I had every symptom that the book describes. Last night I couldn’t put the book down, at the end tried its recommendation and lo and behold my pain from “herniated” disks went away. Thanks again for this.


That is awesome to hear. I have created a small mp3 file for the 12 reminders [1]. If you ever get the pain just play the mp3 file to remind yourself of it again. Good luck! :)

[1] https://clyp.it/chqx0dku#


I haven't read the book, but from watching the video it sounds like the main idea of it is to practice mindfulness.


Not sure if it is that simple. The main idea at least as per what I understood is that there is nothing wrong with your back or structure.

People with multiple herniated discs, "pinched nerves", etc never have back pain yet people with no structural abnormality suffer from paralyzing pains.

The reason is your mind. The logic being your brain tries to hide difficult emotions aka stress and most specifically repressed anger (which you may be even unaware off) by creating physical pain by creating oxygen deprevation in some nerves (which is totally harmless like a cramp but feels like the end of the world to you).

So the pain is real and measurable even though harmless. Regardless, this creates fear and you start believing that the problem in your disc bulge, herniation, etc which is causing it. This is my own interpretation but it's the fear of pain more than pain that makes it into a debilitating pain.

Once you add all the advice on sitting like this and standing like that and getting into the car like this plus problems from your MRI, X Ray and more and more things you are doing wrong, you start believing there is something actually very wrong with you. Yet is not the cause of it but just your repressed emotions.

So long story short as soon as you start believing your body is fine and it your emotions causing the pain, the pain loses its purpose and goes away (that's why people who have been struggling for years get better in 2 to 3 weeks).

The best part is you don't even have to fix the emotions, Just knowing your issue is not structural will make you better.


Can you explain a bit what the method is? If it is not mindfulness, what is it? Thanks


The method is just to realize that the pain isn't due to any structural abnormality but rather due to suppressed emotions. I think the easiest way to learn more about it is to watch Dr. John Sarno's lecture on YouTube (its about 50 mins long and quite easy to grasp at 2X speeds)



It's here (1). Starts around 10 min mark. It's the one he used to give to people who he attended to personally I think.

(1) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OPV-UbSH3KU


thanks!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: