Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

One thing open borders would completely destroy would be the social safety net of many countries. Let’s say there is completely open borders between Sweden and the United States. Sweden has high taxes and an significant social safety net. The United States has low taxes and a non-existent safety net. Over time, people who pay a lot of taxes migrate from Sweden to the United States. People from the United States who are unable to work for whatever reason, migrate to Sweden.

This would also affect government. You either end up with a large underclass that doesn’t have voting rights (see Qatar for example) or else they have voting rights and the laws of the receiving country change to reflect the culture of the immigrants.




Taxes would likely change from income taxes to consumption and property taxes, so it’s unlikely that governments will go bankrupt. More attractive areas of the world will cost more to live in, but it would eventually turn into one large country with pockets of exclusive communities.


>People from the United States who are unable to work for whatever reason, migrate to Sweden.

I think you're overestimating the number of Americans who would have the means to do so, despite not having an income.


If you knew that someone would get a stipend for life, it works I’d be a viable business to them the money to relocate.


They would get the "means" in their destination country through welfare. That's the entire point.


But they wouldn't already have the means, unless welfare was somehow globally distributed and universal.

Which would be a qualitatively better situation for everyone, so I don't see the problem in that case.


Hawaii buys 1-way tickets for homeless people. Picture that on a grand scale, with the United States buying 1-way tickets.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: