Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I think this is the best answer to your question:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QO15S3WC9pg




Thank you for sharing. I accept the first half of his argument, which is why I don't use certain words. However, Coates gives himself the freedom to use certain words he would not himself use in situ. The news article posted appears that there is a word that white people cannot utter in any context, even in describing why they don't use it.


I think his context is as a speaker on stage speaking in a meta way. Did he successfully predict audience reaction?


The speaker in your video used the word "faggot" the same way, with no intent to offend. How should he be punished?

If we're going to have this debate via videos, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRJy48JWiHk


The parent didn't ask for a link to a video, so a link to a video cannot be an answer to the question. Perhaps you could summarise or quote the part of the video that you believe answers the question.


[flagged]


> Does racism still exist? Sure, but not for black people more so than any other race.

Black people in the US make a third less income on average than white people. If this is not the result of racism (either ongoing or the lasting effects of past racism), then please tell me what causes that difference.


Ezra Klein has a stat --- I'm trying to track it down, so this is a paraphrase --- that for any given level of income, a black family in America also lives on a block that is 30% less affluent on average than a white family with the same income level.


I don't agree with the GP about racism no longer being an issue. But if you're saying that racism is wholly responsible for the income gap, then what's your answer to exactly the same question applied to Asians vs white people (25% less income for white)?


The difference is entirely due to asians clustering in expensive coastal cities: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/12/29/the-a....

Adjusted for cost of living, asians and whites make the same household income, while african americans make dramatically less.


That's very interesting. TIL. Thank you.


Men are much more likely than women to commit suicide and be homeless, and many times more likely to be incarcerated. If this is not the result of sexism, please tell me what causes that difference.


One factor in high rates of male homelessness is more agency than women typically have. In other words, they choose to go be homeless as the lesser evil in some lousy situation. It is only one factor and that doesn't change the fact that sexism is actually an issue in such things.

It also doesn't change the fact that this is basically a straw man argument, not pertinent to the question of racism.

Gender and homelessness:

https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/2017/07/g...


> We have had a black president.

Said black president had even the facts of his own birth challenged, including by the man who succeeded him in the backlash.


[flagged]


You're going to go with the verbs "criticize" and "challenge" to describe flagrantly racist birtherism nonsense? Really?


Birtherism is a baseless conspiracy theory.

“Trump is a fuckup President” can at least be argued for. You’ll find even conservatives like George Will and Republican Senators doing so.


The extraordinary claim is parity in racism.


This is embarrassing, don't do this




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: