Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Interesting! I hope the tech works and can reduce potential suffering from mis-read x-rays.

My brother fractured his scaphoid bone during a high school lacrosse game, and the doctor who x-rayed his wrist did not detect it.

He continued living an active life with a broken wrist (he has a high pain tolerance) for several months before the worsening pain sent him to an orthopedic specialist.

Being unaware of the fracture, he had done quite a lot of damage to the bones in his wrist, which wound up needing multiple surgeries and nearly 18 months (!) in a cast to fully heal. He also permanenly lost a bit of that wrist’s range of motion.

I welcome any tool that helps doctors not miss this sort of thing!



I had the almost opposite experience when I fractured a bone in my hand (it was a minor bone chip).

The tech at the immediate care facility saw it, but my ortho didn't when he reviewed it on a follow-up. I had to point out the bone and where it was before my ortho saw it. His response was basically "Oops" followed by removal of the temporary cast/sling and replacing all of that with a reinforced removable brace (which was awesome, because I could easily shower).

I broke my hand after dumping my bicycle taking a corner too fast on a training ride (I was doing around 25 mph) and losing traction under my rear tire. Rode home about 5 miles on that broken hand...


Nice. I was going to post, 'how hard can it be to identify a broken wrist', but you answered me that it does happen.


Apparently it can be really difficult. I had a fall in my house onto an outstretched hand, my doc thought it was broken so she sent me for X-rays. She also told me that it is really easy to miss scaphoid fractures, so if it still hurts in two weeks to come back for more X-rays because sometimes the fracture can be easier to image as it heals. They also said that might not work and if I am still in pain without a diagnosed fracture at week 6 that I would need an MRI.

Thankfully it wasn't broken at all, it just hurt like hell for a week.


nothing is permanent


You may be technically correct, but what’s the point of this comment?

For as long as he is alive, he will have less range of motion in his right wrist than his left, barring advances in nanotechnology bone reconstruction or something.

Millions of years from now, when his body has broken down into petrochemicals, I suppose that yes, his wrist will then have a greater range of motion then it does now.

But that’s hardly relevant.


> For as long as he is alive, he will have less range of motion in his right wrist than his left, barring advances in nanotechnology bone reconstruction or something.

If that is his attitude - and the attitude of everyone around him - then that will likely be the case.

In 'reality' - whatever that means to you - plenty of folks have demonstrated that the body is malleable.

With work, ROM is restorable.


The word 'permanent' doesn't mean what you seem to think it means.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: