Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



> Tracking for advertising is the business model of free content.

Well, too bad, that business model has just become illegal in EU. Publishers will have to make do with old style banners or ads. They can still target ads using the content of the page, assuming readers of the article will be interested in the subject.

... or get consent in a compliant way. Success with that!


But according to what some are saying they are apparently required to provide their content to everyone regardless of whether or not they consent? That’s why I have a problem with. They should be able to say that you must consent in order to use the site.


Or Europeans will have to do with paygates and subscription fees.

There is no "making due". These companies are run very thin already. There is already much less talent, much less pay, and much less quality than most of us would want.

There is a breaking point for providing free content on the internet, and so many publishers are hitting it today WITH TRACKING. So many sites have moved to a X free per month with subscription, or just hard paywalls.

Enjoy your subscription models, because there is no "making due" left, we've already used it all up.


>Enjoy your subscription models, because there is no "making due" left, we've already used it all up.

Fair enough. Sites will either have to provide content worth subscribing to, or else go out of business, and users can still block advertising and tracking and users maintain control over their personal data. It's all win for the consumer.


If that happens, then everyone should be happy. Businesses who don't want to comply with the law can get out of that market and make way for others who do. Consumers have better data protections. Win win.


> They can still target ads using the content of the page, assuming readers of the article will be interested in the subject.

Seems like a perfectly fair assumption to make given that the reader has actively chosen to read said content... Certainly moreso than repeatedly showing them ads for something they already bought weeks ago.


> Do Europeans really think GDPR is a new way to steal internet content without having to pay?

Yes, I believe that was the stated purpose of the legislation.


Based on the entitled behavior in this thread, I seriously consider it.

It it a cultural thing to feel entitled to other peoples work? Or just the agegroup of people on hacker news?


I'll let you in on a little secret. There are many people who will make content that's worth reading long after all the "businesses" that depend on running spyware on their users' hardware are dead. That's not to say that the verge is worth reading.


[flagged]


Nationalistic flamewar will get you banned here, so please don't do it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: