Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I didn't. I looked at their user info and it says nothing - says it was created 9 days ago and the user only submitted 2 redfin articles and nothing else. Normally entrepreneurs and CEOs round here write a short note that they are the founder or CEO or whatever. I didn't put 2 and 2 together. Mae Culpa. But do I now have to double check every submission? Wouldn't it be "normal" to say that you're affiliated if you're affiliated. My hunch says yes.

Personally, I don't think it's ok that a CEO posts here for financial gain - I don't like that motive and I don't like in what direction it would take this site. I feel like this site is like a tech-news link aggregator with a entrepeneurial spin. I don't think it should be used by established businesses to boost traffic. Yes haveing a CEO of any company is of value to the community but only if they are here on merit, and not if they try to manipulate the community.

Like I have said again and again, it is neither here nor there if I agree or disagree with the article - the discussion I want to have is that I think this one: this guy when he submits 2 posts (written by himself on a corporate blog!) one day after another on topics that are guaranteed to cause a stir is cynically trying to boost traffic plain and simple. I don't want up-votes, I just think it speaks of the mob mentality and group-think on HN that you can't dissent or point something out like this without being down-modded.

I am taking it is. Thanks for taking so much time to respond. I hope you see my point of view. I don't see why I keep getting down-modded for it. You seem reasonable and if you say you feel this kind of thing is fine then I'll certainly take you opinion into account and I feel like you're the type of person who would extend me the same courtesy.

Phew!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: