Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Far left very much engages in hate speech. Kill all white people etc etc. You can try to true scotsman that, but you can do the same for the far right.



Who on the left is suggesting that all white people be killed?

Ted Nugent has actually suggested executing Democrats, recently. Not only did he say it, but there was no backlash from the right.


Eg https://www.buzzfeed.com/katienotopoulos/how-trolls-locked-m...

And before you say it wasn’t meant literally - very obviously what Nugent says isn’t literal either. He’s a crazy old man, but he said if you see a coyote you shoot it and allegorically compared this to verbally shutting down Democrats rather than engaging with them. In no way did he suggest shooting Democrats.


I feel fairly confident I don't need to use 'no true scotsman' to argue the fact that no one with a "D" after their name asking Zuckerberg a question today has ever said "Kill all white people."

On the other hand, Cruz wasted our time, and more importantly, the time any other member of Congress would have had to ask something important, asking Zuckerberg about a Chick-fil-A Appreciation Day page that was deleted for 12 hours, yet failed to mention the words "Cambridge Analytica." Hmmmm.


>no one with a "D" after their name asking Zuckerberg a question today

I can't even see where the goalposts have gone.


> Ted Cruz clearly showing that he's a partisan hack. Didn't give a crap about users' privacy or the issues at hand, he had to make it about 'liberal Silicon Valley' and 'conservative persecution'. What a joke.

Couple of different "goal posts" here


Fair enough, although I'm entitled to interpret posts in the pure context of their parent.


Feel like there's a few different things going on in your comment, but I'll focus on -- who are you blaming for "shifting the goalposts"? I believe I'm trying to return focus on the "pure context" of the grandparent; it seems disingenuous to argue I'm, at the very least, the only one shifting the goal posts.


So in the US right is white people and left is everyone else?


No? The hate speech by the left doesn’t have to be against the right. In fact I believe much of hate speech by the extreme left is targeted onto people who consider themselves on the left too; generally hate speech targets the vulnerable or at least the locally unpopular; no reason to think that skews left or right.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: