Via mechanisms similar to either the hygiene hypothesis or hormesis, it's possible those might backfire. This is highly speculative, but:
* the hygiene hypothesis suggests that allergies and auto-immune disorders can arise from having insufficient immune-system challenges, especially when young. Lacking the calibration from an 'expected' or 'optimal' level of dirt/allergens/infectious-diseases, the immune system starts doing unwanted self-destructive things.
* hormesis is the observation that almost everything bad for you also turns out to be good in very-tiny exposures – radiation, poisons, cancer-causing chemicals, etc. It's as if tiny doses trigger beneficial self-repairs to occur even beyond the direct damage received, even as larger doses overwhelm that mechanism.
Removing mild, survivable challenges from the environment could thus leave the immune system less 'tuned' for the full spectrum of challenges it faces (like clearing early cancers). It's an adaptive dynamic system with nonlinear effects, not a simple pool of fixed exhaustible capability.
"Removing mild, survivable challenges from the environment could thus leave the immune system less 'tuned' for the full spectrum of challenges it faces"
Exactly. You want to protect people from, say, Rubella ... but I think we should proceed with caution with things like the cold and the flu ...
* the hygiene hypothesis suggests that allergies and auto-immune disorders can arise from having insufficient immune-system challenges, especially when young. Lacking the calibration from an 'expected' or 'optimal' level of dirt/allergens/infectious-diseases, the immune system starts doing unwanted self-destructive things.
* hormesis is the observation that almost everything bad for you also turns out to be good in very-tiny exposures – radiation, poisons, cancer-causing chemicals, etc. It's as if tiny doses trigger beneficial self-repairs to occur even beyond the direct damage received, even as larger doses overwhelm that mechanism.
Removing mild, survivable challenges from the environment could thus leave the immune system less 'tuned' for the full spectrum of challenges it faces (like clearing early cancers). It's an adaptive dynamic system with nonlinear effects, not a simple pool of fixed exhaustible capability.