I get 35.82 on Safari 11 on El Capitan. What is your hardware? I wonder if I'm slower because I'm on older hardware, because I'm on an older version of OS X, or both?
My hardware is a Mac Pro (Early 2009), 2.66 GHz quad core Xeon, 32 GB 1066 MHz DDR3 ECC RAM, GeForce GT 120 512 MB.
I also for comparison gave it a shot on my Surface Pro 4 (Core i7, 2.2 GHz, 16 GB RAM, Intel Iris 540 GPU).
Here are the results for Chrome 60.0.3112.113. Since I was running on battery I tried this at various power mode settings. Here are the results for Chrome 60.0.3112.113 arranged by power mode setting:
70.18 Best performance
69.61 Best performance (2nd time)
68.03 Better performance
50.84 Recommended
41.33 Battery saver
There are two runs of "Best performance" because I did the tests in the order best, better, recommended, battery saver, and so all but the first may have benefited from caching from the previous. I ran best again after finishing battery saver to get a run of best that would have the same caching benefit the other may have received.
For Firefox 57.0b3 I get:
54.34 Best performance
58.91 Best performance (2nd time)
57.91 Better performance
40.51 Recommended
34.28 Battery saver
For reference, ran the test with Firefox Quantum on the same machine and got a 68.