This stuff always has a warm and fuzzy feeling to it, but imagine the pain of implementing a full game with such physic effects, setting all the particles...
I'm guessing "describing the material and construction properties of every object such that it can be moved, collided, broken, and deformed convincingly." "Convincingly" typically isn't quite what you want either, you usually want "spectacular" which means hand tuning for all breaking/deforming events of interest. Movie effects, for example, start with pure simulation, but nearly always have lots of knobs for artists to play with to give the intended effect (e.g., the last page of this article http://www.wired.com/entertainment/hollywood/magazine/16-01/... ).
Then just don't bother with manual fine tuning. Level designers are using object libraries even now, where they just take a pre-made chair, instead of constructing them out of basic polygons every time.