Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Edit: Now I could easily believe that near future systems could drastically reduce our need or desire for text entry.

That's the only way to really get rid of the need for keyboards- that or literally flawless speech recognition with natural language parsing for commands.

As long as we need to enter text, and don't have voice input, keyboards are the easiest way to enter it quickly/for sustained periods. I dread the day I have to compose a paper on a touchscreen keyboard, unless it is full-sized. And even then, there's no tactile feedback.

Essentially what I am saying is, until either text input is unnecessary or voice recognition takes off, the keyboard paradigm is necessary and useful. Heck, why do you think phones with full physical QWERTY keyboards are still popular among people who really type on their phones?




literally flawless speech recognition with natural language parsing for commands

No way. I can type much, much faster than I can speak. Simpler, strict non-natural commands are much easier than natural language commands (hell, people have difficulties giving and understanding verbal commands all the time) - never mind the fact that languages like English are terribly ambiguous and peoples everyday speech is too filled with local slang.

Also, if I have to talk to my computer, I a) cannot use it in a group environment or, say, when someone is sleeping and b) when I type I can see what I typed and I can edit it if I make mistakes. If I speak commands, I cannot do this. An exaggerated (but still realistic) example: if I type "delete foo" instead of "delete bar" and notice before I hit enter, I can fix the mistake. If I speak "delete foo" then foo will probably be gone before I can correct myself. Finally, what about different words that sound the same? Sometimes spelling or capitalization is the only thing that distinguishes things (eg, file names) - with speech you couldn't do this.

In summary, in my opinion, speech recognition is a terrible form of input for general text input and command input tasks. (It may be useful to augment more traditional input and it can certainly be more than useful (or even required) for disabled people, but for the majority of people and tasks, I don't see the attraction)


It's not that I like speech recognition, it's just the only other option that is even close to a keyboard that I can think of besides a direct brain to machine link.


Sure. I'm just saying that I can't see it ever replacing the keyboard, while your comment kinda sounds like thats what you were suggesting.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: