In the AMA, she linked to her IQ test comment[1], where she made an interesting point about the relationship between higher IQ and night owls[2]. We recently had a discussion about this.
I disagree; as long as Reddit discussions don't become a daily habit here, occasionally posting an interesting thread -- which this one was -- is not really any different from linking to any other site with an interesting discussion.
Or TechCrunch posts, or PDFs, or self-posts, or posts about the iPad. If people didn't post all of the types of content people complain about, HN would be empty indeed.
You need to first be blessed by the Holy Spirit, aka Paul Graham. Otherwise, you might even see the buttons, but your votes have no effect because you're an Outcast.
This probably isn't the full picture, but you can't vote down comments left directly in response to your own comments (for obvious reasons), nor can you vote down comments over a certain age or that are already of a very low score.
[1] http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/aj9xf/by_request_i_hav...
[2] http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/aj9xf/by_request_i_hav...