>> If someone in Greece had, while sitting in their bedroom in front of a laptop, hacked into a US bank and stolen money, would you be surprised if the US wanted to extradite and prosecute?
I'm certainly not surprised the US wants to prosecute, as it seems to want to apply US law to the whole planet.
But I am surprised the in some ways that the system allows it - that person never left Greece. What if the action was something illegal in the US but perfectly legal in the place they are sitting? I don't see that the crime necessarily takes place overseas when what they are really doing is sitting in a room, sending electronic signals from a machine.
>> The idea that "on the internet" is a magical stateless realm has only ever been an idea in the minds of naïve geeks. It has never been reality.
That's not what I'm saying, it's not a stateless realm, but actions taken were not taken in the USA.
I would hope that if you engage in an action illegal in the US but legal in Greece, the Greek government would choose not to extradite, tell the US government to fuck off, and warn you to be careful when travelling abroad.
When one country chooses to extradite someone to another, it's more often because their government doesn't approve of the actions they are accused of either and was presented with sufficient evidence.
I'm certainly not surprised the US wants to prosecute, as it seems to want to apply US law to the whole planet.
But I am surprised the in some ways that the system allows it - that person never left Greece. What if the action was something illegal in the US but perfectly legal in the place they are sitting? I don't see that the crime necessarily takes place overseas when what they are really doing is sitting in a room, sending electronic signals from a machine.
>> The idea that "on the internet" is a magical stateless realm has only ever been an idea in the minds of naïve geeks. It has never been reality.
That's not what I'm saying, it's not a stateless realm, but actions taken were not taken in the USA.