> You presented evidence that he didn't hurt the company so badly that it didn't grow, but not that he didn't hurt the company.
Since no one has presented evidence showing that he hurt his company....
In my book, you don't get to complain about the quality of someone else's evidence unless your evidence is better. And no, "self-evident" doesn't count. YMMV.
At the risk of getting meta, I was complaining about the quality of the evidence for the assertion. I never made any assertions about the company suffering in any way because of this guy.
Since no one has presented evidence showing that he hurt his company....
In my book, you don't get to complain about the quality of someone else's evidence unless your evidence is better. And no, "self-evident" doesn't count. YMMV.