Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Unusual whistled speech may reveal what humanity’s first words sounded like (bbc.com)
37 points by Thevet on May 28, 2017 | hide | past | favorite | 11 comments



>> Herodotus described a group of cave-dwelling Ethiopians. “Their speech is like no other in the world: it is like the squeaking of bats,” he wrote. We can’t know for sure which communities he was describing, but Meyer says that several whistled languages can still be heard in Ethiopia’s Omo Valley.

In Herodotus' writings, like in many other ancient sources, the name "Aethiopian" (and not Ethiopian) was used for people from Sub-Saharan Africa:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aethiopia

If people in Ethiopia have a whistled language it has probably nothing to do with the "bat-like squeaks" mentioned in the article.


Considering that the word barbarian comes to us from Greeks describing any language that wasn't Greek as the like the baying of sheep I wouldn't take "bat-like squeaks" too literally.


Herodotus was notable among the Greeks for trying to accurately record history. I don't think we can safely assume that he embellished this story.


Maybe he didn't embellish his stories, but he certainly wrote down a lot of things that were clearly folk tales and hearsay and of which he had no way to check the veracity. You can't really make anything of his reporting of "Aethiopian bat squeaks".

Oh and btw- he was not the only (ancient) Greek interested in a more rigorous look at history. You have probably heard of Thucidides, Xenofon etc.


Being notable for something doesn't mean others can't be notable for it to.


The Pirahã language of South America can also be whistled or hummed, and has other interesting characteristics , like lacking words for numbers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirah%C3%A3_language


Whistles can be a fun way to control a system, the DSP needed to do this is really simple, and whistles really punch through the noise floor like nothing else!

I've always used discrete change in pitch as the "symbol", so commands are encoded as (for example) UP UP DOWN UP, so this only depends on the relative pitch change between short whistles.



Reminds me of Michael Rooker's character from Guardians of the Galaxy, with his whistle-controlled arrow.

I'd love to hear an example of how this might work with English. It's hard to imagine ex nihilo.


The article does give an example of how it works in Spanish. There is an audio sample linked of the sentence 'En todo el mundo hay hombres que hablan silbando' being whistled.

https://soundcloud.com/bbc_com/entodoelmundo


Reminds me I still need to learn how to wistle :(




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: