Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Last year when donating specifically to Thunderbird was made possible on mozilla.org, I donated to the project because it has provided a lot of value over the years.

Recently I started looking at the discussions on the tb-planning mailing list and it looks like we'll get a revamped (fully rewritten) Thunderbird. That sounds like a very long project to me - probably a few years just to bring it to what Thunderbird already provides today. Plus the extensions system needs to be revamped as well (similar to what's happening on the Firefox side with XUL ones going out). Getting Exchange calendaring done is also not a priority because of the complexity and the effort needed. So it looks like we will get a better maintainable product after some years. I'm not sure if that's going to appeal to many people to donate.

I'm happy with Thunderbird and some extensions that I use regularly, with the only exception being calendaring support for Exchange being very poor and unreliable (even with the Exchange EWS Provider extension or with external solutions like DavMail). Since I don't like taking risks with email client alpha or beta releases because of the fear of data loss (and with huge mailboxes, even detecting data loss would be a chore), I'll just stick with the current version and hope that the new revamped one comes in a stable form sooner (of course, I will donate periodically). I'm excited and afraid!



I still use Evolution with its Exchange provider for work e-mail and Thunderbird for personal e-mail.

I like Thunderbird and have used it for well over a decade, and I really hope development continues on it. There aren't a lot of mature open source desktop e-mail clients out there these days and I hope Thunderbird stays maintained for a long time.


Are you referring to this addon? https://github.com/Ericsson/exchangecalendar

It seems to be dead currently, seems it stopped working in the latest Thunderbird release and the author is unresponsive.


When I read http://www.dedoimedo.com/computers/software-development-canc... I considered it a bit tongue-in-cheek/satire/something. When I read about things like TB rewrite, I think maybe it was just... true?


I switched to using EM Client for Exchange stuff, it's got an impressive feature set.

http://www.emclient.com/


That fully rewritten Thunderbird will apparently be based on Electron, the Javascript GUI.

The CPU-thrashing, memory hungry, battery killer Electron. I do not want an email client, or any other software that is meant to run constantly in the background, to be written in Election.


Thunderbird is already written with a JavaScript GUI running on top of web rendering engine so even if this is true it's just a lateral step


Why are you spreading this information, when you know no such thing has been decided?


The issue was discussed previously on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14156251


Yes, there has been lots of discussion, but no decision.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: