Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Breaking the rules/doing something a little risky can lead to some of the most magical moments in your life.

Sure. But part of the reason for that is that those actions are risks.

> seems like an excessive punishment

I didn't see any kind of punishment in the story. I saw a consequence for an action. He didn't die because he broke the rules. He died because he made a fatal mistake by slipping into a hot, acidic pool.

> I feel terrible for what happened in this instance

I feel sorry for the people that he hurt as an indirect result of his actions, but not for the guy himself.

> it's never the individuals fault it's the systems fault. Could we not also perhaps apply this philosophy to safety notices/warnings/education in this tragedy?

I strongly disagree with Amazon's philosophy, in that case. From what I've heard, there are many, many posted warnings, marked trails, and rangers patrolling to educate people. The park's almost 9,000 km^2. At some point, you've got to consider that a best effort was made to provide guidance for safety, and anything that happens as a result of going against that guidance is on whoever did it. He died because he did something stupid, not because the signs/rangers/trails/his 2nd grade teacher didn't stop him.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: