Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> Its pretty much a monopoly, now that Google seems to have officially closed the book on ever supporting postgresql.

Uh, how? I wouldn't be surprised to see a Cloud SQL-like managed Postgres service from Google.

While there's obviously some overlap in the potential market for any relational datastore service, Spanner doesn't really overlap with a cloud Postgres service as much as Cloud SQL does.




I would be. its been years and google and has been building out various pieces of infrastructure around mysql - including cloud spanner.

the issue is that the migration path of self hosted mysql to cloud sql to spanner is pretty well defined. I dont see postgresql being strategically important or relevant to google for anything.

if I was a startup deciding on my database, there's a lot less compelling reasons to choose postgresql from the point of view of long term viability. hell, I can pretty much do a back of the envelope calculation on how much will it cost me to support 100 million users on mysql.

Is it safe to think that Evernote and Snapchat - startups who are giant success stories - are google mysql hosted? (in some form.. maybe even spanner)

So uber, snapchat, Google, Evernote and a clear cut path for upward scale.

I have very less hope for postgresql on google cloud.


> its been years and google and has been building out various pieces of infrastructure around mysql - including cloud spanner.

What does Cloud Spanner have to do with MySQL? It's neither API nor SQL-dialect compatible with MySQL. If there are MySQL bits used somewhere in the implementation, they are well hidden, and irrelevant to users.

> the issue is that the migration path of self hosted mysql to cloud sql to spanner is pretty well defined.

So what? Were there a Cloud SQL-like Postgres offering, the same would be true; Spanner is no closer to MySQL than Postgres. (If anything, it's SQL dialect is a little closer to Postgres's dialect than MySQL's, though not so much that you'll get away without doing substantial conversion going from either.)


You keep saying this - have you actually talked to them? Find some PMs and send a few emails. Postgres is definitely in progress.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: