Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't think you understand this at all.

Yes, different modes of transportation cost more. The problem is charging different services a different rate on that mode of transportation.

Sure, a wireless network can cost more, and people can pay more. What net neutrality is about protection from being charged more for bits coming from a competitor. This protection is both good for the customer and the market competition. Without it in fact you can't have market competition. All you will end up with his monopolies. I personally think it is high time that internet access be regulated as a utility and decoped from any secondary media businesses.

A wireless customer is paying for wireless access and should not have any bill charge difference for the bandwidth they paid for regardless of the backend source.

The best analogy I can come up with is this. There are 2 major stores in your town that sale widgets.

Company A owns a single widget store. Company B owns a single widget store and a toll road.

This toll road is the ONLY way to get to company A's and company B's widget store. This is mostly due to lobbying and unfair protracted company B takes part in to ensure that there are no other roads. The problem is that company B stops and ask each driver where they are going when they enter the toll road. They charge one price to cars who are going to company B's widget store and a higher price to cars going to company A's widget store. Both drivers will be on the toll road for the same time as its only a small strip of road, but still the only road.

You do see the problem right?




Yep, I see the problem. I just telling that it is not a FCC role to fight monopolies.

As long as traffic coming in and out at same rate for every provider, FCC should relax and watch.

Moreover, I know information theory, so I see no problem at all for hacker like me. I will just use uuencode/uudecode.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: