I find that the unlimited and instant choice I get with Spotify make me enjoy the music less. There are many songs that I constantly pass over on Spotify but am absolutely delighted to hear on the FM radio.
Happy to hear that I'm not the only FM-ist. I also love "FM quality" ... twice I bought an album after loving it on radio, and was disappointed because the clear mix changed the feel of the songs.
Lastly, remember how it felt to listen to a tape. You didn't want to skip, so you just let the music play and go with the flow.
All of this is the paradox of choice and free will. We think we want ability to do exactly all we want when we want but it turns out it's not so clear cut.