There is one thing this site seems to be missing: an "under construction" icon, preferably in the form of an animated GIF. :P Because of this omission, I can only give it 4/5 stars, just for reminding me of the days when something like http://oreilly.com/catalog/9781565920637 was what passed for a way to find stuff on the internet.
This is my new favorite web page, it's genius! What goes around, comes around. I can't wait until 2015 when some comedian creates the web-2.0-izer to what has become of hackernews.
I'm in High School and I remember creating websites using FrontPage (and notepad of course). We even used FrontPage in elementary school, so I think most younger HN'ers might remember what it is.