Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That puzzle needed more clarification. The solution talks about having two padlocks affixed to the same box, but I can't imagine any kind of box that can have 2 padlocks affixed to it unless the box is specifically designed to allow 2 locks.



A quick search for padlocked box will show many, many such boxes. It seems more common for there to be space for two or more locks, than for just one.


My point is that the puzzle should be updated to inform the reader that designing the right kind of box is a part of the puzzle:

"Jan and Maria each have plenty of padlocks, but none to which the other has a key. Using only the padlocks, keys, and a custom-designed box, how can Jan get the ring safely into Maria’s hands?"


You could always take a one-lock box and build an adapter that accepts two locks, and keeps the box locked if either lock is present.


This just isn't true. I mean, yes they exist, but the norm is overwhelmingly a single latch with room for a single lock.


Without a third party showing sales of padlock boxes with and without space for two or more locks, there's no actual way of being SURE which is more common.

Even if there are ten times as many boxes available that only have space for a single lock, what matters in the case of the puzzle is, a box with space for two or more locks is readily available. Suggesting in the puzzle "by the way the box has space for two locks" really kind of destroys the "puzzle" aspect.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: