Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Switching from ECS to GKE (Google Container Engine) currently. Both seem overcomplex for the simpler cases of deploying apps (and provide a lot of flexibility in return), but I have found the performance of GKE (e.g. time for configuration changes to be applied, new containers booted, etc) to be vastly superior. The networking is also much better, GKE has overlay networking so your containers can talk to each other and the outside world pretty smoothly.

GKE has good commandline tools but the web interface is even more limited than ECS's is - I assume at some point they'll integrate the Kubernetes webui into the GCP console.

GKE is still pretty immature though, more so than I realized when I started working with it. The deployments API (which is a huge improvement) has only just landed, and the integration with load balancing and SSL etc is still very green. ECS is also pretty immature though.




The Problem is that GCP doesn't run an RDS service with PostgreSQL. And external vendors are mostly more costly than AWS RDS. Especially for some customer homepages where you want to run on managed stuff as cheap as possible.


This is sad for sure. The new MySQL cloud 2.0 is really good, and if you use a DB agnostic ORM you can probably make MySQL work for quite a while. Sad to lose access to all the new PG features though, and I would love if Google expanded their cloud SQL offerings..


This is what made me use aws as well


I'm admittedly biased, but have you checked out Docker Cloud? http://cloud.docker.com


While not Docker Cloud specifically, when we eyeballed UCP we found it very underwhelming when pitted against Kubernetes.

To us it appeared yet another in a sea of many orchestration tools that will give you a very quick and impressive "Hello World", but then fail to adapt to real world situations.

This is what Kubernetes really has going for it, every release adds more blocks and tools that are useful and composable targeting real world use (and allow many of us crazies to deal with the oddball and quirky behavior our fleet of applications may have), not just a single path of how applications would ideally work.

This generally has been a trend with Docker's tooling outside of Docker itself unfortunately. Similarly docker-compose is great for our development boxes, but nowhere near useful for production. And it doesn't help Docker's enterprise offerings still steer you towards using docker-compose and the likes.


Not to bash, but the page you linked is classic Docker - it says literally nothing about what "Docker Cloud" is.

"BUILD SHIP & RUN, ANY APP, ANYWHERE" is the slogan they repeat everywhere, including here, and it means even less everytime they do it. What IS Docker Cloud? Is it like Swarm? Does it use Swarm? What kinds of customers is Docker Cloud especially good at helping? All these mysteries and more, resolved never.


I hadn't heard of it, actually. However it doesn't seem to support GCP which removes it from contention for us unfortunately.


so am I (I'm YC alumni) .. but RDS is too important for us to move away from it. Let me put it this way - if you had an RDS equivalent in Docker Cloud, lots of people would switch. Docker is more popular than you know.

Heroku should be an interesting learning example to the tons of new age cloud PAAS that I'm seeing. Heroku database hosting has always been key to adoption.. to an extent that lots of people continue to use it even after they move their servers to bare metal. The consideration and price sensitivity to data is very different than app servers.


I believe this is tutum that they bought some time ago. I tried tutum before with Azure. After deleting the Containers from tutum portal, it does not clean everything from Azure. Today the storage created by tutum is still in my Azure storage. LOL.


Docker Cloud still requires BYO cloud, however.


For the record, the Kubernetes dashboard comes pre-installed on all masters on GKE. So the UI is there, albeit not integrated into the Gcloud console.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: