Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> All it would take would be for a judge to send a single one to jail for the weekend

On what grounds? None of them have broken the law and the order, should it come about, would be for Apple to perform this work, not specific employees (or, if they resign, ex-employees). What would be the route for the government to compel specific individuals – who do not own or control Apple's code or data, and individually are not the only people who can perform this work – to do this?



1) Judge rules that Apple must disclose the information.

2) Judge issues a subpoena to an employee that another employee has said is capable of retrieving the information.

"Do you have the capability to retrieve this PIN number?"

"Yes, your honor."

"Will you do so?"

"No, your honor."

"I find you in contempt. Lock this gentleman up."


> "Do you have the capability to retrieve this PIN number?"

The answer to this question is no, since the person would be no longer employed by Apple, would not possess the source code, and would not possess the signing key.

Even if you assumed that the court could force Apple to disclose these items to somebody who is now a third-party, it may be the case that there isn't any person who is capable of doing this. Are the same people at Apple responsible for code signing and writing the code necessary to do this?


> > "Do you have the capability to retrieve this PIN number?"

> The answer to this question is no

Doesn't matter. All the judge needs is to notice in your face that you do have that capability.

Don't believe me? Look at this case:

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2011-10-07/news/ct-met-lo...

According to the judge:

"What I saw in his face was just defiance. He was not going to testify in this double homicide case because he wasn't going to testify. That's all there was to it. So I saw pure scorn for the judicial system in the defendant's face."

Because the judge didn't like his face he gets 20 years for contempt.

20 years!


Doesn't matter. The Judge merely collects all the pieces and then Orders them to work together.

If it reaches anything approaching this point (it won't) stopping it basically requires an individual to commit to doing the work then sabotaging the device when presented with it.

That's the act of civil disobedience. And you can expect to spend more than a night in jail should you grow the balls to do it.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: