Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Form the linked article:

> allocates benefits as higher earnings nearly evenly across the income distribution

OK by me. Note that it doesn't allocate benefit to idle owners f investment income.

> Even after taxes, 27.6 percent of increased earnings go to families in the top 40 percent of the income distribution.

"top 40%" is rather silly bucket. That includes basically the median family, all the way to billionaires.

> Over 25 percent of the increased earnings are collected back as income and payroll taxes

(aka effectively a tax on businesses that pay the minimum wage)

It takes massive concern trolling to argue that this effect is worst than not raising the minimum wage

Pardon me if I overlooked the anti-minimum-wage camp yelling "lower taxes on the working poor!"




> "top 40%" is rather silly bucket. That includes basically the median family

No, top 40% does not include "basically the median", by any remotely reasonable standard.


That's why he said basically, it's pretty much the upper half which yes, includes middle class families and billionaires and is a silly bucket to put in one group.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: