Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Selling bottled fresh air to China (independent.co.uk)
28 points by chdir on Dec 16, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 27 comments



This "article" is a great advertising win for this company. Clearly, independent.co.uk picked this up from another site which probably originated as sponsored content or a press release.

>The company started marketing the product in China less than two months ago, but now that the first shipment of 500 bottles is sold out, another of 700 bottles is on its way.

500 bottles, at less than $30 bottle, in two months, in China. Thats not impressive in the least. Proportionally we are talking about a fraction of a fraction of a percent of the urban Chinese population, for a good sold online that is far from "luxury" pricing.

Jesus, there are probably self-published Kindle eBooks about Sonic the Hedgehog fanfic that have sold quicker than that.

When legitimate websites give attention to insignificant products such as this, they are creating the trend, not reporting on it.


Also, what defines a "bottle"? How long does it last? Are they spending $30 for a can of Perri-air that lasts 5 seconds? Is there a mask involved?

Inquiring minds want to know, and it appears this "journalist" isn't the least bit concerned in what could be very strange details.


I don't feel that they picked it up from another site. The company probably hired a PR firm. The PR firm helped The Independent write this aritcle.


Perri-air? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiabeNR_q0U

Actually, a Chinese entrepreneur started doing this in 2012: http://www.geeksofdoom.com/2012/09/18/china-is-now-selling-c...


Having just watched Spaceballs this is the first thing that came to mind haha.


I came here looking for this exact comment... truly, life is imitating art.


There's an irony in shipping practically-empty bottles in trucks farting out smog to a region buying them because of smog.


Assuming for a minute that bottled air is a viable solution to smog, it's only the prestige of "exotic Canadian air" that necessitates the long shipping distance. Bottling filtered air from a relatively local source might work... but only if your factory could generate net negative emissions.

And anyhow, to have a health impact, we're talking about large quantity concentrators for those lug-around supplemental oxygen machines. These look awfully small to have any impact long term:

http://vitalityair.com/products/bottled-goodness.html

Anecdotal: I once tried purchasing a similar Oxygen can at a high-altitude ski resort as a sort of "stamina inhaler" on a heavy powder day. A good puff would return one's breath to normal pretty quickly, but the can ran out after a few hours of occasional use. So, at best these can be used as an ersatz, non-medical inhaler.

On the other hand, the market for air filters is still booming.


Yeah - imagine the energy and resources needed to pack and ship bottles of air halfway around the world, all because your current country is too polluted.


> a restaurant in in Zhangjiagang city recently started charging patrons for fresh air, after owners bought air filtration machines for the establishment and added a surcharge to people’s bills for the operation costs.

Having lived in Mumbai for 2 and a half years, this to me actually kind of makes sense.

Surcharging people will probably vanish once air filtration becomes more common, or ubiquitous (I've never been, so wouldn't know).

But in Mumbai, there's really nothing like stepping off the hot and polluted streets, into an air conditioned place with clear air.

Of course, the issue needs to be fixed at source, and this is so obvious it's hardly worth stating. But somehow, having lived in a polluted asian city, none of this surprises me, unfortunately.


Spaceballs was not supposed to be a documentary.


The idea is much older than Spaceballs. For example, this story was published in 1929:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Air_Seller


Yes! I was thinking Spaceballs as soon as I read the title.


This girl was really onto something: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wyrFWbGiGOc


Had to look it up, she was trolling the VC community http://allthingsd.com/20110401/rachel-sequoia-comes-clean-hi...


> “In Silicon Valley people think you can drop any idea these days and get it funded,” said Abhyanker. It may well be true: Share the Air got multiple funding and business development inquiries, he said.

Hilarious!


Is this for real?

I guess it is. This is the kind of outcome that, if you read about it in a science-fiction story, it'd break your immersion. Absolutely ridiculous, though the company seems to have struck gold of some sort.


Oxygen bars have been around for a long time.


Maybe they can burn the empty bottles?


No. It's not for real. These are novelty/gag gifts produced in a run of 500 bottles, and it's picked up by the Daily Mail doing an article on Those Crazy Chinese. They advertise about 150 breaths per $30 bottle.

The notion that anyone is selling an actual air supply here to any substantial portion of the population is sensationalist in a fairly racist manner; Like http://gizmodo.com/5897678/chinas-urine-boiled-eggs-are-a-cu... , a "hot commodity" consumed by a few hundred elderly people in one neighborhood of one city. Or the show at Wangfujing market in Beijing of skewered, roasted scorpions & seahorses, consumed exclusively by tourists. "Fast Food Beijing Style" - http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1041266/Scorpion-keb...

Generalizing an extremely rare cultural or entrepreneurial novelty over 1.36 billion people is somehow okay when the generalization level is "China". Not enough people know enough about China to understand that these exoticist stereotypes are not founded in statistics, but in a freak show / link bait mentality.

.

Take a statement which is more true than "Chinese people buy canned air":

.

"Crazy Americans Run Out Of Vomit, Have To Purchase Fake Vomit For Social Purposes"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fake_vomit

Has sold tens of thousands of units. Surprisingly, not a cultural touchstone.

.

"Americans So Oversexed They Require Penis Cage To Prevent Erections"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chastity_belt_(BDSM)#Chastity_...

Big deal in BDSM subculture. Not an "American" thing, though.

.

"Americans Are Now Buying Dedicated Cars To Use From Their Superyachts"

http://www.wired.com/2015/11/marine-mono-supercar-superyacht...

Technically true. But what does the headline imply?


Has everyone given up on making the air in Beijing better?


The great song by NOFX, Eat the Meek comes to mind.

The factory mass producing fear, bottled capped Distributed near and far sold for a reasonable price The people, they love it, they feed it Brush with it, bathe with it, breathe it Inject it direct to the blood It seems to be replacing love

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=93cVK8Zaxss


What's the difference between their products and the oxygen cylinders used in hospitals?


Huh, how about setting up a local shop filling bottles with air from a purifier? /s


The Chinese have humor too? Not really news.

That and when a business has running costs they pass that onto customers.

Strange article.


Nobody mentioned The Lorax movie where O'Hare air sells air to the smog ridden city. :-)


Spaceballs.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: