Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

My point is, what about all the other people? The world is not divided into White, Black, Asian and Spanish-speaking. There are Indians, Central Asians, Arabs, Persians...

Even 19th century racialists in their ignorant understanding of the world didn't lump 2/3 of the world's population into a miscellaneous category.




> My point is, what about all the other people?

The common racial categories today (of which others are subcategories) are (though different names are sometimes used) Black, White, Asian/Pacific Islander, and Native American. Sometimes Pacific Islanders are considered a separate high-level group, rather than part of a top-level group with Asian. [0]

(Hispanic is an ethnic group that is usually treated as cutting across racial groups.)

> There are Indians, Central Asians, Arabs, Persians...

In terms of the usual racial categories, that's Asian, Asian, White, and White.

> Even 19th century racialists in their ignorant understanding of the world didn't lump 2/3 of the world's population into a miscellaneous category.

Actually, I'm pretty sure the old Mongoloid from the long-dominant threefold racial category -- which is the closest parallel in the old scheme to the modern Asian category but is even broader -- certainly did so even more than one could argue that "Asian" does in the dominant modern scheme.

[0] See, e.g., the categories used by the US Census (and the US government more generally, which do break out Pacific Islanders separately) http://www.census.gov/topics/population/race/about.html


Having an event for black and hispanic folks doesn't preclude them from having an event for asian folks. Not every event has to be pan-inclusive.


You say that like making an event 'inclusive' is some kind of chore. In fact, what we're talking about is stopping people at the door because they have the wrong skin color.


That is not at all what is being done here; in fact, that's a grievous misrepresentation of what they're doing.


[flagged]


And extending an invitation for a 20 minute phone call is worse than traveling across the country to do a recruiting event at an elite college with minuscule Latino and African American enrollment how?

The "fuck off" is a nice rhetorical touch, too.


> In fact, what we're talking about is stopping people at the door because they have the wrong skin color.

What makes you think that YC is categorizing by skin color rather than, as is more typical, self-identification?


Yeah what would Black and Hispanic people know about that?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: