Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Having conclusive evidence that a program doesn't work (or even is harmful) is significant. How effective is it for actually getting such programs stopped? Have any been?


Some have, but many persist for years (e.g. Scared Straight).


Scared straight is highly effective PR. Hood looking young people getting yelled at by scary men? Possibly crying? It's like schadenfreude for "civilized" society.

I don't understand how policy leaders can look at hard numbers and say, "fuck it, let's keep funding it."


Tucker: My expert would totally disprove that.

Abbott: Who is your expert?

Tucker: I don’t know, but I can get one by this afternoon. The thing is, you’ve been listening to the wrong expert. You need to listen to the right expert. And you need to know what an expert is going to advise you before he advises you.

- The Thick Of It




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: