Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | pressanykey's commentslogin

I am a daily bike commuter in Berlin. I think dickish people are evenly spread on all transportation modes. Difference is, dickish car drivers kill people, dickish biciclists don't. There has been 9 deaths of biciclists in Berlin in 2017[1] so there is definetely a reason for higher identifiability for car drivers.

[1] http://adfc-berlin.de/radverkehr/sicherheit/aktionen/62-geis...


How comes you both assume the author is male? She is called Sabine Hossenfelder.


How come you assume a person named Sabine must 100% be a woman?

And how come you assume that even if said person indeed has the XX chromosomes (to be nominally classified as a "woman"), that they also self-identify as a woman and prefer the adjective "she" over "he" or some other?

See how far this rabbit hole goes?

It's easy why they assumed the author is male: they don't care who the author is, and didn't read their name on the blog. I read the first 6-7 paragraphs of the post and didn't bother to read the name either. And even if I had, "Sabine" as a name doesn't tell me anything about the gender (not a name we have in my country, nor a very well know one, like Mary or Helen or something that everybody would guess). Heck, there are Spanish men called "Maria".

Had I made a comment I might have used either "they" or assumed it's a man, mostly because statically for things posted at HN, it would be true.


I dunno about the rest of you, but I clicked on the link to her Twitter account, which so far has much higher quality stuff than this thread on HN.

Some fun links:

"Lightning makes new isotopes" http://www.nature.com/news/lightning-makes-new-isotopes-1.23...

"P-values--abused but not abandoned" (includes some nice background on p-values for those of us for whom the concept is a little fuzzy) http://sciencenordic.com/p-values-abused-not-abandoned

A cute video of Feynman answering the question of whether you're seeing an object, or only the light from an object, when looking at it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8aWBcPVPMo

A single-molecule magnet: https://physics.aps.org/synopsis-for/10.1103/PhysRevLett.119...

...and all that's just in the last 24 hours. She's got a fantastic Twitter feed for the science-interested.


Sorry, I was not aware that Sabine is not obvious in english. The picture in the top right could also have been a hint.

It is not about it being "100% woman" but about "male" being the default. I think it is telling that the assumption seems to be physics -> male. If this would have been about social issues or fashion, maybe the people would have checked before assuming male gender?

I don't say it does not happen to me too, but if it happens, I think it is good to raise awareness.


>Sorry, I was not aware that Sabine is not obvious in english. The picture in the top right could also have been a hint.

Hmm, I managed to miss the picture too!

>It is not about it being "100% woman" but about "male" being the default

Is it the default because of bias though, or just because it's just more common -- and people tend to assume based on frequency?


The gender of the name "Sabine" is not obvious to me. I wish English had a good gender neutral pronoun. "He or she" is too formal sounding. "They/their/them" is too informal sounding.


I wonder why you feel that singular they is informal? There's nothing wrong with the construction. It's attested as far back as 14th century. And, as you mention, it certainly fills a void in the language.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they


Because I don't care enough to pay attention.


Note also the picture of her at the top of the page.


A greek director also made a movie based a very similar idea http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1859446/?ref_=nv_sr_1

Also check out his newer movies like The Lobster... really good movies!


Yes.

Hannover - Hannoveraner

Bremen - Bremer (regular might be Bremener like Essen - Essener)

Jena: People who live there are "Jenaer", people who are born there are "Jenenser".


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: