Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | nitinpande's comments login

Nice! Had not read about this concept earlier. Will research more on it. Thanks for sharing!


Fair points. Would love to hear the other 'anythings' that can replace DNNs (something that optimises and stores knowledge that can be passed down generations to further build more sophisticated systems).

I thought DNNs are a good framework to contemplate the reason as well as mechanics of our existence. And using the framework I came to the thought that we probably do not have any grand purpose.

Also, I think saying that the universe is a DNN system is different from saying that it is 'a system'.

Agree DNNs are not magical for someone who has been working on them forever but for a new entry into the ML field, believe me they are pretty magical :)


I might just not be sure what you mean by DNN here. A deep neural network is a specific architecture, consisting of input and output layers of discrete nodes, connected through many hidden layers of nodes, with each node able to perform simple operations on the signals passing through it. So I don't see any way you could model the universe or a seed as a literal DNN; I interpreted the main reason for the analogy that they're a system in which storing knowledge (in an NN, as the weights of activation) is an intrinsic part of the way the system is active.

From there, you really can interpret most things as systems with embedded knowledge that both defines their activity and is adjusted by new activity. The position of each atom in an object is intrinsically both the information about that object, and the way that it behaves: as changes are made, the atoms react accordingly, affecting the behavior of the system.

You can view a seed as a "trained model" only insofar as the information on how to become a tree is encoded in the seed. The specific properties of DNNs (hidden layers that increase in abstraction) aren't really present, and anything can encode information: a set of clouds could be considered a trained model on how to make a hurricane, or a single person could be viewed as containing a trained model on how to start a company. Seeds are highly optimized through evolutionary pressure, but that applies to all complex systems, not just DNNs, and optimization is not just non-unique to DNNs but not even necessarily present in the architecture.


https://mentii.com - a peer to peer career advisory network. The site features are listed here - https://mentii.com/features.


Anshuman Bapna, the CEO of mygola.com has written a neat blog post on the 3 Reasons Why Mygola is the World’s Best Travel Planner - http://blog.mygola.com/2013/10/3-reasons-why-mygola-is-world...


thats really cool :)


We use jekyll for our blog( https://mentii.com/blog ) and use disqus for the commenting system. If you are comfortable using markdown and need something lightweight and fast, then jekyll is perfect. On the other hand wordpress has a lot of themes and plugins to choose from and pretty much everything that you'll ever need is already there. If there are non developers who are going to contribute to your blog, then wordpress would be a better option IMHO.


Thanks a lot ! :)


The request meeting sends 3 specific times for the other person to accept one, thus making it easier to setup a meeting with them.


Oh wow .. never knew that. Thanks for letting us know.


Thanks a lot! Sumit (my cofounder) is sending you a mail. Lets connect.


And to add to this .. We have some karma already in place and its called "Respect". Users can go to profile of others and give them Respect (by clicking on the Respect button) which helps in bubbling up engaged mentors in the community.


Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: