Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> What's up with all the Ayn Rand? Misogyny, xenophobia and unvarnished greed aren't exactly admirable characteristics

The big problem with Rand is that she's downright nasty to the other side. So people feel attacked and tune themselves out to her good ideas. Rand's anti-politicking, pro-individualism, pro-triumph, pro-innovation, pro-going against the grain, and so on. She rails against the very real, very nasty backroom deals that give privilege and blessing to companies who can work the political system at the expense of companies built by clueless-to-the-law engineers and scientists. She makes a heck of a lot of good points...

...but she's really nasty about it, incredibly unfriendly and unsympathetic to the motives of people who have other politics than hers. It makes it easy for people with other views to tune out everything she wrote, even though there's a lot of value in it.




Oops. I just thought it was an amusing anecdote, but this isn't a constructive direction.


It was an amusing anecdote that started with a harsh indictment of anyone who likes Ayn Rand's writing. Are you sure you didn't expect people to be offended at what you said? Are you, perhaps, being a little disingenuous here?


Ah, but if one aspires to an ego the size of Howard Roark's, he wouldn't be offended by anything whatsoever.


What does that have to do with liking Ayn Rand's writing?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: