Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This is next level! Thinking back to my language textbooks, this would be brutal for me on a mental level.

Do you think it could work as well with a short story or novella? Perhaps one of the books by Olly Richards? I find the dialogues in textbooks absolutely mind numbing most of the time and while easy books for learners aren't that interesting anyway, at least it's a full story and not people ordering lunch or a trip to the doctor for the 99th time!




The thing is, the dialogue has to be short to really stick to your brain!

Like, less than a minute.

Repetition is key, and if the text is too long, it’s not repeated enough.

To me, it’s not mind-numbing until I can “sing along” because I know it by heart. And then I move on to the next, slightly harder, text.

You don’t have to always listen to it actively, you can put it in while doing other work.

Some language self-learner books are better than others.


I'd really like to give this method a go. I'm trying to learn French and struggling with the listening component. Do you have any sources for dialogues that you used?


I used the Langenscheidt and PONS courses for Polish in the past. But I think they are only available in German.


Ah okay. I think most of the dialogues from the books I'm thinking of were between 3-5 minutes. Something shorter might work better, indeed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: