Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Elagabalus was of Arab heritage and he was a priest who worshiped a representation of Baal, the very controversial and very foreign God he wanted to make #1.

It's no surprise that people were upset.




Yeah, 2000 years ago. I don't expect a modern publication to call it the worst thing he did


It may have been the "worst thing" he did politically. Do you not understand that?


The article is a book review, that is not the context I see when I read that condemnation. Maybe the book makes that case, but the review does not.

And, referencing your other post, I don't think the scenario in seventeenth century England is comparable to third century Rome. The Roman pantheon was already on the downswing, allowing a priest of Elagabalus to become emperor. A century later Constantine would make a similar move, leading to the still dominant Christianity. Had Heliogabalus been a competent man the move may have been a huge success.

Finally, the personal attacks aren't necessary.


Yeah, sorry about the attack.


... and ancient trolling followed naturally.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: