Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Few theories:

1. Ukraine is behind disinformation campaign to temporarily boost morale.

2. Russia is behind disinformation campaign to mount an element of surprise (an all out offensive was suddenly ordered this morning).

3. Social media is facilitating disinformation with variety of incentives for its participants ranging from merchandising (as was for Ghost of Kiev) and internet points (DCS World footages)




Apparently the women with bandages is also fake:

https://twitter.com/NathiTwala4/status/1497499545437093889


This is quite worrying. Again its not clear who is behind this disinformation campaign and who stands to benefit from it.

I don't want to say it's Ukranian intelligence because it seems illogical to me but would confirm my suspicion that it is sabotaging its own: that they could use disinformation to shore up international support at the risk of inevitably being debunked and losing credibility.

Again, cui bono, who benefits here from this disinformation? It is still not clear because why would you raise the morale of your enemies troops on purpose in the opening hours of the war?

This is an endless hall of mirrors, whatever it is they are doing, its working, its raising the cost of discovering truths while lowering social cost of emotional outbursts (seen that already here from someone accusing me of being a Russian bot) to further distort reality.

Everybody needs to remain calm, and question what they are seeing is real or fake, before choosing to disseminate it.


At the same time, deutschewelle this approach of “everything could be fake news” reduces the speed with which support to the oppressed side may be provided. We have seen this over the past several months with European leaders travelling to Moscow one by one to show how much they’re achieving with their diplomacy.

This is modern Information Age warfare - morale is everything and with screens and videos it is possible to disarm/arm enemies with just media. The defending side will also use every opportunity they can to propagate a message, even if they can’t verify it. The other side will also do everything they can to tarnish that message with imperfections and counter stories.

What I would like to say here is that just like one can get carried away with emotional outbursts and hysteria, one can also get carried away in the opposite direction. That is over-restraining your emotions and repeating “let’s just wait and see” over and over. Until, that is, it turns out one day that the other side has been running a secret concentration camp or is bombing innocent people to acquire power or some other horror.

It does not surprise me that some have thrown such accusations in response to these kinds of comments. Business is rational, and war is often great business.


I wouldn't be surprised if it was beardnecks on 4 Chan or some other group etc. who are starting disinformation just for lolz. Sad world but sadly reality.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: