Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

If deficient plants have been operated successfully for this long, the implication to me is that their operators have proven responsible enough to handle it.

A lack of air bags is not noticable until your car crashes.




Sure, but what you're claiming is that air bags are missing based on never having seen them operate.


No, they are missing because the car had been built before the invention of airbags. It's uncontestable that currently operating reactors generally lack certain safety measures we'd have added if we built them today.

The question is if we nevertheless deem them 'safe enough'.


> It's uncontestable that currently operating reactors generally lack certain safety measures we'd have added if we built them today.

It is, because it is also a tautology. To me it has no bearing over the point we're discussing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: